Simple Hop Tests after ACL Injury Hold Prognostic Value for Future Outcomes
Functional or physical performance tests play a crucial role in evaluating the recovery process following an anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury and subsequent reconstruction (ACLR). Among these tests, hop tests have gained prominence due to their simplicity and effectiveness in assessing lower-limb function. A recent systematic review published in BJSM has shed light on the prognostic capacity of hop tests following ACL injury and reconstruction, providing valuable insights for clinicians and patients alike.
The study, conducted following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines, aimed to synthesize data on the prognostic value of hop tests. The researchers analyzed the associations between hop tests, expressed as a limb symmetry index (LSI), and future knee-related outcomes, focusing on studies with a follow-up period of at least three months. The review also explored the impact of test batteries, which included hop tests alongside strength measures, on predicting future knee-related outcomes.
Incorporating data from 42 studies involving over 13,000 adolescents and adults, the meta-analyses revealed compelling findings. The performance on single-forward hop and repeated-forward hop tests was significantly associated with various positive outcomes. Notably, individuals with better hop test performance showed twice the odds of returning to pre-injury sport up to three years post-ACLR. They also had 2-4 times the odds of experiencing improved self-reported symptoms and function up to 15 years post-ACLR. Additionally, achieving a ≥90% LSI on the single-forward hop test was linked to a 50% reduced odds of radiographic osteoarthritis 5-37 years post-ACLR.
However, it is important to approach these findings with caution, as the review identified that 65% of the included studies had a high risk of bias. Nevertheless, the results highlight the clinical significance of hop tests as prognostic tools, providing valuable information for both clinicians and patients. Hop tests can serve as indicators of potential future outcomes after ACL injury and reconstruction, empowering healthcare professionals to guide patients along their rehabilitation journey effectively.
Despite the positive prognostic capacity of hop tests, the study also revealed that achieving adequate hop test performance does not automatically reduce the risk of subsequent knee injury. Therefore, it is crucial to understand that while hop tests contribute to overall rehabilitation progress, additional measures and interventions may be required to mitigate the risk of future knee injuries.
The study’s implications call for the continued use of hop tests in ACL rehabilitation and as part of return-to-sport assessments. These tests offer immediate feedback to patients and can be instrumental in motivating and encouraging adherence to rehabilitation protocols. By harnessing the prognostic value of individual hop tests and hop test batteries, clinicians can empower patients on their path to recovery and facilitate informed decision-making.
In conclusion, the systematic review emphasizes the importance of hop tests as prognostic tools in the context of ACL injury and reconstruction. Their simplicity, ease of administration, and significant associations with future outcomes make hop tests a valuable addition to rehabilitation protocols. However, clinicians should consider the limitations of the available evidence and adopt a comprehensive approach that includes additional measures to ensure the best possible outcomes for patients recovering from ACL injuries.
How To Handle Emotional Release, Q&A with Art Riggs
The healing femur
How can lifeguards best recover… resting, running, or foam rolling?
About The Author
